Topic: Build amusement park
Introduction of panelists
Opponents
・Jiro: He is a farmer,50years old. He grows vegetables in his farm.
・Kazuo:He is a farmer,45years old. He breeds many cows and pigs.
Supporters
・Eiji: He is a tour conductor.
・Haruhiko: He is a village mayor.
Important points raised in the direction
・If they build an amusement park, some farmers will lose their farms.
・Farmers have run their farms for long time, so they can't look for a new job.
・Building a amusement park brings new jobs for people who can't have a job.
・Many people will visit their village if a amusement park is build.n
The outcome of the discussion
・They will make a new brand of their cows and other food.
・They will build a plant and animal park.
My opinion
I think it is the best way to build an amusement park which people can experience farming. I think farmers don't have to lose their job if they do so.
How effective I though the discussion was and how it could have been better.
I thought their moderator got their ideas in shape very well. I could understand easily. But I though they should give a concrete example about the financial problem they proposed.
2011年11月17日木曜日
2011年11月9日水曜日
Report of discussion 2
Topic:Exterminate bird or not
Panelists
*Yoshiyuki: He is opposed to exterminate.He likes bird watching.
*Kiku: She is opposed to exterminate too. She loves birds.
*Yuri: She is for exterminating. She has two sons.
*Etsuko: She is for exterminating too. She is a farmer.
Supporter's opinion
*The song of birds is very noisy, so many people can't sleep.
*Droppings are very insanitary and soil city.
*Birds bring virus.
*Birds eat vegetables which made in farm.
Opponent's opinion
*Birds come the city because human destroyed their dwellings. In other hand, birds problems are caused by human. So human should not kill them.
*We should use a machine which drive birds without killing.
The outcome of the discussion
*Residents clean droppings.
*Yoshiyuki and his friends collects eggs.
*The city catch few birds.
My opinion
I thing it is no use catching birds. We can't reduce the number of bird without kill them.
How effective I though the discussion was and how it could have neen better.
I tought their each opinions and situations were clearly, so I could understand easily. I think they should speak more loud voice.
Panelists
*Yoshiyuki: He is opposed to exterminate.He likes bird watching.
*Kiku: She is opposed to exterminate too. She loves birds.
*Yuri: She is for exterminating. She has two sons.
*Etsuko: She is for exterminating too. She is a farmer.
Supporter's opinion
*The song of birds is very noisy, so many people can't sleep.
*Droppings are very insanitary and soil city.
*Birds bring virus.
*Birds eat vegetables which made in farm.
Opponent's opinion
*Birds come the city because human destroyed their dwellings. In other hand, birds problems are caused by human. So human should not kill them.
*We should use a machine which drive birds without killing.
The outcome of the discussion
*Residents clean droppings.
*Yoshiyuki and his friends collects eggs.
*The city catch few birds.
My opinion
I thing it is no use catching birds. We can't reduce the number of bird without kill them.
How effective I though the discussion was and how it could have neen better.
I tought their each opinions and situations were clearly, so I could understand easily. I think they should speak more loud voice.
登録:
投稿 (Atom)