Report of discussion 2

Topic:Exterminate bird or not
Panelists
*Yoshiyuki: He is opposed to exterminate.He likes bird watching.
 *Kiku: She is opposed to exterminate too. She loves birds.
*Yuri: She is for exterminating. She has two sons.
*Etsuko: She is for exterminating too. She is a farmer.

Supporter's opinion
*The song of birds is very noisy, so many people can't sleep.
*Droppings are very insanitary and soil city.
*Birds bring virus.
*Birds eat vegetables which made in farm.

Opponent's opinion
*Birds come the city because human destroyed their dwellings. In other hand, birds problems are caused by human. So human should not kill them.
*We should use a machine which drive birds without killing.

The outcome of the discussion
 *Residents clean droppings.
*Yoshiyuki and his friends collects eggs.
*The city catch few birds.

My opinion
I thing it is no use catching birds. We can't reduce the number of bird without kill them.

How effective I though the discussion was and how it could have neen better.
I tought their each opinions and situations were clearly, so I could understand easily. I think they should speak more loud voice.